Hospital Mergers Drive Knee Replacement Costs to Double in North Carolina
Data from Serif Health shows that a knee replacement at Mission Hospital in Asheville costs more than twice as much as the same procedure at Catawba Valley Medical Center in Hickory, highlighting the price impact of hospital monopolies.
Recent pricing disclosures show a stark contrast in knee-replacement costs: Catawba Valley Medical Center in Hickory billed about $16,000 under a Blue Cross Blue Shield plan, whereas Mission Hospital in Asheville charged roughly $40,000 for the same procedure. Analysts attribute the gap to hospital consolidations that give larger systems bargaining leverage over insurers, a trend evident in other states such as Florida’s Holmes Regional Medical Center and Colorado’s Banner North Colorado Medical Center.
While hospital representatives claim differences stem from scale, technology, and patient population, economists note that reduced competition drives up prices, which insurers then pass on to all policyholders. The issue has spurred regulatory attention, with the FTC proposing a task force on healthcare mergers and several states enacting laws to curb anticompetitive acquisitions. Ongoing lawsuits, including a class action filed by Asheville restaurateur Katie Button, allege that Mission Hospital’s monopoly harms consumers and employers by inflating insurance premiums.
Why it matters
Higher hospital prices raise insurance costs for everyone, stressing household budgets and the broader economy.
In this story