Liberals Revive McCarthy-Era Tactics While Trump Brands Democratic Socialists as Reds
The article argues that liberal Democrats are condemning Howard Zinn while echoing Cold-War anti-communist tactics, as Trump weaponizes accusations of socialism against his political opponents.
In this commentary, the author asserts that modern liberal Democrats are simultaneously vilifying historian Howard Zinn and reviving the anti-communist zeal that historically undermined left-wing coalitions. He points to President Donald Trump’s use of Cold-War-style accusations, echoing Roy Cohn’s tactics, to paint Democratic Socialists as dangerous reds amid the nation’s 250th anniversary. The narrative revisits Zinn’s 1950s ordeal, when FBI agents interrogated him and threatened his family because he opposed the expulsion of suspected communists from the American Veterans Committee, a multiracial veterans group later fractured under pressure from figures like Ronald Reagan.
The article suggests that liberal preoccupation with policing the left weakens their own political power and plays into Trump’s strategy of sowing division between centrist Democrats and progressive insurgents. It calls for a renewed commitment to Zinn’s principle of using history to shape present action, warning that failure to heed past lessons could leave dissenters silenced. The piece concludes that unity, not internal purges, is essential to counteract authoritarian impulses.
Why it matters
It highlights how internal liberal conflicts may unintentionally strengthen authoritarian rhetoric and undermine progressive movements.
In this story