NFL coaches and executives rank Matthew Stafford among elite quarterbacks for 2026

In one outlet’s 2026 quarterback tier rankings, Matthew Stafford was classified as a Tier 1 passer, receiving 48 votes from a group of 21 executives and 29 coaches, while only two placed him in Tier 2. His 2025 campaign, highlighted by a career-high 46 touchdowns, 4,707 passing yards and an MVP award at 37, impressed the majority of the panel. Commentators emphasized his intelligence, pre-snap processing and flawless execution of play designs, with one former head coach noting his exceptional arm talent and defensive reading.

A general manager lauded his ability to bring schemed concepts to life, and a defensive coach highlighted his precise arm angles. The dissenting votes reflected lingering doubts about his age, durability, and the limited sample size of his late-career resurgence. Overall, the voting underscores a near-consensus that Stafford belongs among the league’s elite quarterbacks.