Briev
Live
Sport

Police admit clerical mistake shifted blame in Kyle Shanahan crash report

Palo Alto police confirmed a data entry error wrongly blamed another driver for the collision involving 49ers coach Kyle Shanahan.

A reporting error by the Palo Alto Police Department incorrectly assigned responsibility for a crash to the driver opposite Kyle Shanahan, the San Francisco 49ers head coach. Lieutenant Nicolas Martinez confirmed that Shanahan's account was correct and that the mistake happened during the transfer of the report to the state system. The department is now amending the record and clarified that officers have discretion to issue or withhold citations after a collision.

The 49ers kept the incident hidden from July 14 until July 25, which led to public doubts about possible preferential handling. While no citation was issued to Shanahan, the police emphasized that neither party received special treatment. The delayed disclosure has sparked ongoing questions about transparency surrounding the incident.

Why it matters

It reveals how a police reporting error and delayed disclosure can fuel perceptions of bias in high-profile traffic incidents.

In this story

Kyle Shanahanclerical errorPalo Alto policecollision reporttraffic citation49ersstate databasepublic disclosure