American Jews Face Heightened Antisemitism and Internal Splits Ahead of High Holy Days
Rabbis say U.S. Jewish congregations feel vulnerable due to rising antisemitic threats and sharp internal disagreements as the High Holy Days approach.
With Rosh Hashana and Yom Kippur imminent, U.S. rabbis describe a climate of insecurity among their congregations, citing an unprecedented rise in antisemitic hostility and stark divisions over Israel’s policies. Rabbi David Ingber of Romemu notes that many liberal members are conflicted by anti-Zionist sentiment while also confronting claims that Israel lacks a right to exist. Michael Masters of the Secure Community Network warns that threats now stem from a broad spectrum of actors, from foreign proxies to domestic white supremacists, prompting the group to run safety webinars and on-site training.
Recent violent episodes—including a Manhattan synagogue assault, a truck-ramming in West Bloomfield, Michigan, and an arson in Jackson, Mississippi—highlight the danger. Leaders such as Rabbi Rick Jacobs stress the need to balance fear with the spiritual significance of the holidays. Major Jewish bodies are pressing Congress for a $1 billion increase in the Nonprofit Security Grant Program to better protect houses of worship.
