Arizona homeowner loses $475K house after $977 HOA debt, sold for $8K
Toby Newton’s Mesa home, bought for $475,000, was foreclosed after he fell $977 behind on HOA fees and auctioned to the association for $8,172.
In 2022 Toby Newton purchased a four-bedroom home in Mesa for $475,000. After losing his employment and developing diabetes, he fell $977 behind on quarterly homeowners-association assessments and sought to negotiate a payment schedule, offering $50 then $200 monthly, which the Superstition Springs Community Master Association declined. The association filed foreclosure in November 2024; as the case proceeded, court filings showed his liability grew to $1,311 in missed fees, $1,042.09 in plaintiff’s fees and $3,345 in attorney fees, totaling $6,579 by October 2025.
The property was auctioned that month and bought back by the HOA for $8,172. The episode occurred as Arizona enacted Senate Bill 1494, raising the thresholds for HOA foreclosures to 18 months delinquency or $10,000 owed and requiring boards to attempt reasonable payment plans. Newton’s partner, Sherrie Patten, started a GoFundMe to help the couple cope with the financial and emotional strain.
Why it matters
It shows how minor HOA debts can trigger foreclosure and highlights new state rules meant to protect homeowners.
In this story
