Borrell questions link between Spanish citizenship and voting rights amid grandchildren law dispute
Former EU foreign policy chief Josep Borrell said voting rights need not be tied to Spanish nationality, prompting debate after the Supreme Court halted registrations under the so-called grandchildren law.
In a televised interview, former EU high representative Josep Borrell argued that Spanish citizenship should not automatically confer the right to vote, challenging the controversial "grandchildren law" that grants nationality to descendants of those exiled under Franco. His comments followed a Supreme Court order that temporarily blocked the inclusion of these new citizens in the Electoral Census of Absent Residents, unless they can demonstrate exile.
Borrell pointed to Germany, where nationality and voting rights are distinct, and to Italy’s specific constituencies, to illustrate that many European states separate the two concepts. He also objected to labeling the beneficiaries as "absent residents," noting they have never resided in Spain. The government, via minister Óscar López, has defended the law’s application and described the court’s injunction as an undemocratic overreach.
Host Xabier Fortes asked whether opening a debate was appropriate; Borrell replied that a reasoned discussion should be allowed. The exchange highlighted a growing political divide over how Spain should treat the descendants of exiles in its democratic process.
Why it matters
The debate affects who can vote in Spain, influencing the political integration of descendants of Franco-era exiles.
How this story developed
- Sep 9 PSOE set to approve citizenship bill for Sahrawis amid concerns over Morocco
- Sep 10 The Supreme Court ordered a temporary halt to the electoral registration of foreign nationals who obtained Spanish citizenship under the Ministry of Justice's 'grandchildren' instruction, citing risks to election integrity.
- Sep 13 The court’s injunction now requires applicants to provide proof that their ancestors were exiles.
- Sep 13 The citizenship proposal cleared the Justice Committee and is now scheduled for a full congressional vote.
In this story
Related stories
15 in this thread