Brooklyn tenant installs $114 fake window, ignites online debate over NYC living conditions
Brooklyn resident Sophia added a $114 light-box that mimics a window to her windowless bedroom, prompting social-media critics to call the setup dystopian.
In a Brooklyn apartment lacking any windows, resident Sophia installed a $114 light-box that projects a realistic daylight scene, dubbing it a “fake window.” She demonstrated the device in a video that attracted more than 1.4 million views, explaining that the plank of wood behind the wall blocks real light and that the light box “saved my life.” The post provoked a wave of online backlash, with critics labeling the arrangement as “dystopian,” “prison-like,” and evidence that New Yorkers “live like prisoners.”
Despite the criticism, Sophia argues the inexpensive solution lets her cope with high rent and a windowless space. Other locals such as Brooklyn artist Reina Vargas and Australian expatriate Shreya have posted similar setups, saying the illumination helps them stay sane while working or painting. The episode underscores the ongoing challenge of limited natural light in some New York apartments, even as the city was recently crowned the most romantic city in the United States.
Why it matters
It highlights how high rent and cramped housing push New Yorkers to adopt unconventional solutions for basic daylight.
In this story
