Centrelink resumes repayments for nearly 150,000 income-apportionment debts after legal validation
Around 147,000 Australians are being asked to repay debts calculated using an income-apportionment method that a court once ruled unlawful, after new legislation retroactively validated the approach.
Centrelink is reactivating debt recovery for roughly 147,000 Australians after a 2025 court decision found the income-apportionment method unlawful. The approach, used from the 1990s until 2020, spread a claimant’s income across multiple reporting periods when pay-slip information conflicted with Centrelink data, mirroring the controversial Robodebt system. A Federal Court test case involving Victorian plumber Matthew Chaplin led to a ruling that the method was illegal, but a December 2025 law subsequently validated all existing apportionment debts.
Services Australia has sent notices explaining the resumption of repayments and informing recipients of the Income Apportionment Resolution Scheme, which allows claims for up to $600 in compensation until January 2027. Critics, including Adelaide resident Jodie, argue the debts are based on outdated income estimates and are difficult to contest, especially when online dashboards show no balance. The agency maintains the debts are calculated from actual earnings provided by claimants, not from averaged tax data.
Why it matters
The story shows how a retroactive law is forcing thousands to repay disputed welfare debts, raising concerns about fairness and government accountability.
In this story
