Columnist Calls National Book Awards a DEI Checklist Amid Minority Winner Surge
Bret Stephens argues the National Book Awards have become a “DEI checklist,” pointing to a recent dominance of minority authors among winners and finalists.
In a recent column, Bret Stephens labeled the National Book Awards a “DEI checklist,” citing a striking shift toward minority authors. From 2015 onward, nine of ten fiction awards and every non-fiction award were given to writers from minority backgrounds, and the 2026 finalists mirrored that trend, featuring nine minority authors and a single white, Jewish, straight male. Stephens argues the prize has lost its national character, serving instead a narrow cultural agenda.
He suggests the focus on minority voices functions as a form of literary reparations that may backfire, stifling dissenting perspectives and deterring aspiring writers. The columnist warns that such politicization could erode readership and the diversity of American letters. He concludes that suppressing certain books is a quieter way to destroy culture than burning them.
Why it matters
The critique highlights how award politics may shape literary culture and influence which voices reach readers.
In this story
