Compass's private listings keep many homes hidden from public search tools
Compass, the nation's biggest independent brokerage, uses a three-stage marketing plan that keeps a large share of listings off public MLS databases, limiting buyer access.
Compass, which holds roughly 21.6% of the national real-estate market and dominates up to 80% of listings in certain metros, employs a three-step approach that begins with a "Private Exclusive" listing among its 340,000 agents. Homes then move to a "Coming Soon" preview on select platforms before finally entering the public MLS. The brokerage says this method cuts sale time by 34% and adds 4.6% to sale price, but opponents contend that without broad exposure a property's true value cannot be gauged.
Examples from a San Francisco condo seller and a Florida homebuyer show that off-market listings can lead to missed higher offers and reduced visibility. Critics also warn the model may enable Compass to collect fees from both sellers and buyers. State legislators in several regions are considering restrictions on such private listings, and a New York attorney-general investigation is underway.
Why it matters
Hidden listings limit buyer choice and may distort home prices in markets where Compass dominates.
In this story
