Conservation Group Sues EPA for Withholding Lobbyist Emails on Dicamba Reapproval
The Center for Biological Diversity sued the EPA to obtain communications showing former industry lobbyists now in EPA leadership influenced the reapproval of the herbicide dicamba.
The Center for Biological Diversity brought a federal suit against the Environmental Protection Agency on Thursday, seeking all communications related to the 2025-2026 reapproval of the herbicide dicamba. The organization had submitted ten public-records requests for emails and memos between April 2025 and March 2026, but the EPA has not complied, claiming “unusual circumstances” and noting that some files are under review by the White House and the agency’s administrator.
The lawsuit focuses on former industry lobbyists—Kyle Kunkler, now deputy assistant administrator for pesticides, and Nancy Beck, a senior official in the Office of Chemical Safety and Pollution Prevention—who, together with deputy Lynn Dekleva, were involved in accelerating the dicamba assessment despite court rulings that the chemical’s drift harms crops, gardens, and wildlife. The plaintiffs contend that one outlet administration appointed these lobbyists to key EPA positions and is now concealing their role in a decision that affects millions of acres of soybeans and cotton.
The Center asks a judge to compel the EPA to produce the records within 30 days. The case highlights concerns over potential conflicts of interest in pesticide regulation.
How the sides frame it
MODERATE AGREEMENTLeft-leaning coverage emphasizes EPA’s collusion with Bayer to set weak dicamba rules and the health and environmental risks, while centrist coverage highlights the conservation group’s lawsuit demanding withheld lobbyist emails and EPA’s lack of transparency.
LEFT
EPA is portrayed as enabling Bayer to self-regulate a hazardous herbicide, compromising health and the environment.
CENTER
The focus is on the legal fight to obtain withheld communications and EPA’s refusal to comply with records requests.
The left emphasises
- EPA let Bayer choose lenient mitigation measures for dicamba
- dicamba’s drift harms neighboring crops and is linked to liver cancer and non-Hodgkin lymphoma
- the agency’s leadership includes former industry lobbyists
Related stories
2 in this thread