Court blocks Trump administration's order to keep Michigan coal plant operating
A federal appeals court ruled that the Energy Department exceeded its authority by using emergency powers to keep the J.H. Campbell coal plant in Michigan open past its planned shutdown.
A three-judge panel of the D.C. Circuit Court rejected the Energy Department’s claim that an emergency existed to keep the 64-year-old J.H. Campbell coal plant in Michigan operating beyond its scheduled retirement. Energy Secretary Chris Wright had invoked emergency powers, arguing the plant was needed for reliable regional power.
The court, joined by Michigan, Illinois, Minnesota and environmental NGOs, held that the Federal Power Act’s emergency clause is intended only as a last-resort measure and that no such emergency existed. Judge Cornelia Pillard warned that overturning the plant’s carefully planned shutdown would cause unnecessary disruption. The ruling curtails a broader Trump-era strategy to prevent the closure of half a dozen coal plants, a move that opponents say inflates consumer bills and adds avoidable air and water pollution. Officials noted the plant cost at least $135 million in 2025 alone, and Ted Kelly of the Environmental Defense Fund called the order unlawful and harmful to health.
Why it matters
The decision limits federal use of emergency powers to keep outdated, polluting coal plants running, affecting energy costs and environmental health.
How the sides frame it
HIGH AGREEMENTBoth camps report the same court decision that the Department of Energy lacked authority to keep the Michigan coal plant operating.
LEFT
Coverage frames the ruling as a defeat of the Trump administration’s attempt to keep an aging coal plant open, emphasizing the lack of a genuine emergency and the role of environmental groups.
RIGHT
Coverage frames the ruling as a legal determination that the DOE exceeded its statutory authority, highlighting the court’s statutory analysis and the plant’s planned retirement.
The left emphasises
- court blocked the Trump administration’s emergency order
- no emergency existed under the Federal Power Act
- the decision curtails a broader Trump-era strategy to keep coal plants open
The right emphasises
- DOE lacks emergency power under the Federal Power Act
- the court focused on statutory text and placement
- the plant’s retirement was coordinated with regulators and would replace it with less polluting, lower-cost generation
In this story
