Court raises sentence for man who killed toddler under his care
A three-judge panel upheld the prosecution’s appeal and increased the prison term for Noor Ab Manap, who pleaded guilty to culpable homicide after a toddler died while in his custody.
In a decision delivered by a three-judge bench, the court found the eight-year sentence previously imposed on Noor Ab Manap inadequate and permitted the prosecution’s appeal, leading to an increased custodial term. Noor, a father of four, had been responsible for the care of a toddler named Adam in Kampung Janglau, Rompin, after the child’s parents paid RM250 per month. The child suffered fatal internal abdominal injuries, including mesenteric tears and significant bleeding.
The judges emphasized that the trust placed in an adult caretaker carries heightened responsibility, especially given the child’s vulnerability. While acknowledging Noor’s first-time offender status, remorse, and family obligations, the court rejected arguments that his financial stress should heavily mitigate the sentence. Deputy public prosecutor Solehah Noratikah Ismail represented the state, and the defence was led by Aida Rahayu Abdul Rahman and Amara Abu.
Why it matters
The case highlights how courts assess caretaker responsibility and sentencing when a child dies under entrusted care.
In this story
