Debunking the myth of Scotland’s exceptional progressiveness
An opinion piece argues that Scotland’s self-image as uniquely liberal masks rising racism, sectarianism and far-right activity.
Since the 2014 independence referendum, Scotland has cultivated a belief that it is inherently more liberal and welcoming than the rest of the United Kingdom, a view amplified by the SNP’s dominance and the country’s refusal to back Brexit. The article highlights research showing high levels of Islamophobia, a surge in hate-crime charges, and waning public support for migrants and LGBT+ communities, indicating that deep-seated racism and sectarianism remain unaddressed.
It cites statements from former first minister Humza Yousaf and scholars Neil Davidson and Satnam Virdee about Scotland’s reluctance to confront its colonial past and systemic bias. The failed Gender Recognition Reform bill and the rise of far-right protests across cities from Glasgow to Orkney further demonstrate the disconnect between the myth of exceptionalism and lived experience. The piece calls for honest self-reflection to align Scotland’s self-image with its social realities.
Why it matters
It challenges a widely held national narrative, exposing social divisions that affect policy and cohesion.
In this story
