Defense and prosecutors reach informal pact to limit evidence in Anthony murder case
Karmelo Anthony’s attorneys and Texas prosecutors agreed to a “gentleman’s agreement” that bars both sides from presenting certain character and family background evidence during his upcoming trial.
Court documents reveal that Karmelo Anthony’s lawyers negotiated an informal “gentleman’s agreement” with Texas prosecutors to prevent the introduction of potentially prejudicial background information in his murder trial. Under the pact, neither side may reference family violence witnessed by Anthony or discuss Austin Metcalf’s character, reputation, or any prior violent or bullying incidents. Prosecutors also agreed not to present Anthony’s school disciplinary record or his cellphone data, while the defense limited its evidence to the stabbing at Kuykendall Stadium on April 2, 2025.
The move follows Anthony’s ongoing effort, led by civil-rights attorneys including Russell Wilson and Brooke Cluse, to overturn his conviction. His team is preparing a recusal hearing for Judge John Roach and plans to file a motion for a new trial if the judge steps aside. The outcome of the recusal and new-trial motion is expected by August 24.
Why it matters
The agreement shapes the evidence that will be heard in a high-profile murder trial and could affect the outcome of Anthony’s appeal.
In this story
