Democratic Whip Katherine Clark defeats two progressive challengers in Massachusetts primary
House Democratic Whip Katherine Clark won the Massachusetts 5th District Democratic primary, beating challengers Jonathan Paz and Tarik Samman.
Katherine Clark, the second-ranking Democrat in the House, retained her seat in the 5th Congressional District after a decisive primary victory over former city councilor Jonathan Paz and Harvard Law School researcher Tarik Samman. Clark’s campaign amassed $4.5 million, dwarfing the $88,500 raised by Paz and the $43,800 collected by Samman, according to FEC filings. The contest centered on positions regarding the Gaza war and the influence of pro-Israel lobbying, with the American Israel Public Affairs Committee backing Clark despite her recent criticism of Israeli policies.
Clark has previously voted to cut $3.3 billion in U.S. military aid to Israel, citing concerns over Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s government. While she continues to support Israel as a sovereign Jewish state, she remains critical of its leadership. Clark’s next general election will be unopposed, following a 74%-26% win over Republican Caroline Colarusso in 2022.
Why it matters
The primary shows how debates over Israel policy are shaping Democratic contests in safe districts.
How this story developed
- Aug 18 Mike Rogers courts Jewish Democratic voters in tight Michigan Senate contest
- Aug 20 A Senate primary debate has been set for September 15.
- Aug 27 A recent gathering of Michigan Democrats highlighted lingering divisions over El‑Sayed’s comments on Israel and domestic terrorism.
- Aug 31 Arab‑American leaders in Dearborn publicly endorsed Abdul El‑Sayed.
- Aug 31 Report noted that Arab Christian voters in Michigan tend to lean Republican while Muslim voters have largely backed El‑Sayed.
- Sep 1 Mike Rogers launched a television ad attacking El‑Sayed over past statements on sexual issues and the synagogue attack.
- Sep 1 Senator Bernie Sanders said a limited group of Democratic officials and major donors may prefer El‑Sayed to lose the general election.
- Sep 1 El‑Sayed defended his earlier criticism of Independence Day fireworks on “The Breakfast Club.”
In this story
Related stories
17 in this thread