Edinburgh residents take super-hostel plan to Court of Session over heritage concerns
Residents have filed a statutory appeal to the Court of Session to overturn the approval of a 544-bed “super-hostel” conversion of four Category A-listed townhouses in Edinburgh’s New Town.
Residents opposing the conversion of four Category A-listed townhouses at 14-17 Atholl Crescent into a 544-bed “super-hostel” have lodged a statutory appeal at Scotland’s Court of Session. The project, approved on appeal by a Scottish Government planning reporter in July, would introduce capsule-pod accommodation into Edinburgh’s West End, a UNESCO World Heritage area. More than 280 objections were submitted, contending the high-density proposal is unsuitable for the historic district and could set a precedent for similar developments.
The appeal argues the reporter misapplied the 2017-2022 World Heritage Site Management Plan instead of the current 2025-2035 version and failed to set conditions limiting the number of beds or pods. It also questions the impact assessment on nearby residents and notes that the city’s Development Management Sub-Committee never voted on the scheme. Campaign spokesperson Philip Flockhart emphasized the need for transparent, democratically scrutinised planning decisions.
Why it matters
The case could shape how heritage-site developments are reviewed and approved across Scotland.
In this story
