Beta The Briev beta is out. Free on iPhone via TestFlight — install it in under a minute.

Join the beta ↗
Briev
Live
Politics
CROSS-SPECTRUMBROAD COVERAGE

Fact-check finds no proof Abdul El-Sayed pledged support to Muslim Brotherhood

Republican Senate candidate Mike Rogers claimed Democrat Abdul El-Sayed supports the Muslim Brotherhood, but a fact-check found no evidence of such a pledge.

At an August gathering in Turkey, Ali al-Qaradaghi, secretary-general of the Qatar-based International Union for Muslim Scholars, praised the Oct. 7 Hamas attack—referred to as the “Al-Aqsa Flood”—as the catalyst for recent political breakthroughs in the West. He asserted that without the attack, Zohran Mamdani would not have become New York City’s mayor and Abdul El-Sayed would not have mounted a $73 million Senate bid in Michigan.

The cleric’s remarks tied the electoral successes to what he described as the Zionists’ shame after the assault. The International Union for Muslim Scholars is linked to the Muslim Brotherhood, an organization the governments of Egypt, Bahrain, Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates have accused of using Islamic discourse to facilitate terrorism, though it denies the claim. Mamdani’s campaign leveraged anti-Israel sentiment and included a pledge to arrest Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, while El-Sayed, a Democratic Senate candidate, has vowed to withdraw U.S. military assistance to Israel. Both figures have faced scrutiny for endorsing slogans that glorify Palestinian militancy.

How the sides frame it

LOW AGREEMENT

Left-leaning coverage highlights El-Sayed’s defense of Muslim-American identity and criticism of U.S. policy, centrist coverage centers on a fact-check debunking claims he pledged to the Muslim Brotherhood, while right-leaning coverage stresses his alleged ties to controversial figures and groups.

LEFT

Frames El-Sayed as a defender of Muslim-American identity who condemns U.S.-Israel actions and focuses on everyday voter concerns.

CENTER

Frames the story as a fact-check that finds no evidence El-Sayed pledged support to the Muslim Brotherhood and labels the accusations as Islamophobic.

RIGHT

Frames El-Sayed as linked to extremist or controversial allies and portrays his past as problematic despite attempts to moderate his image.

The left emphasises

  • defends Muslim American identity
  • condemns United States and Israel’s involvement in the war on Iran and Gaza
  • voters care about practical concerns like groceries and gas

The right emphasises

  • shares stages with controversial personalities such as Hasan Piker and DSA members
  • has been photographed with Nation of Islam affiliates and praised by clerics linked to the Muslim Brotherhood
  • efforts to scrub prior left-wing content and deny being a socialist
Get the beta ↗