Federal Hate-Crime Trial of Buffalo Shooter Payton Gendron Begins Jury Selection
Jury selection starts Tuesday for the federal hate-crime case against Payton Gendron, the Buffalo supermarket gunman facing a possible death sentence.
Jury selection is set to begin Tuesday in the federal trial of Payton Gendron, the white supremacist responsible for the May 2022 Buffalo supermarket massacre that left ten Black victims dead, including Celestine Chaney. Gendron faces over two dozen federal hate-crime charges and more than a dozen firearms counts, with prosecutors pursuing the death penalty under the Biden administration’s 2024 decision. He has already received a life sentence after pleading guilty to state murder charges, and his lawyers will not dispute his guilt but will seek to spare him execution by presenting mitigating factors.
Victims' families express mixed feelings about capital punishment, with some, like Buffalo Common Council member Zeneta Everhart, acknowledging its deterrent value while others remain ambivalent. The case underscores a broader pattern of anti-Black violence, as FBI data show Black people remain the most frequent target of hate crimes nationwide.
Why it matters
The trial will determine whether the federal government seeks the death penalty for the deadliest recent anti-Black hate crime in the U.S.
How the sides frame it
HIGH AGREEMENTBoth camps report the start of jury selection and the charges, but the right-leaning coverage highlights the shooter’s white-supremacist identity and the Biden administration’s role in seeking the death penalty, while the centrist coverage sticks to basic procedural facts.
CENTER
Centrist coverage presents the trial’s procedural details and charges without added commentary.
RIGHT
Right-leaning coverage emphasizes the shooter’s white-supremacist label and the political context of the death-penalty pursuit.
The right emphasises
- white supremacist responsible for the massacre
- prosecutors pursuing the death penalty under the Biden administration’s 2024 decision
- victims’ families express mixed feelings about capital punishment
In this story
