Fire investigator defends arson conclusion in 2003 Colorado Springs house fire
Veteran fire investigator Kirk Schmitt testified that his original team’s findings still support arson in the 2003 fire that killed three Nicholls children.
Kirk Schmitt, who entered the Nicholls home shortly after the 2003 blaze, affirmed that the collaborative investigation that identified arson remains solid, noting that at least six investigators examined the scene. The fire claimed the lives of children Jay, Sophia and Sierra, and led to the convictions of Deborah and Tim Nicholls, both serving life sentences. A 2023 discovery of a Colorado Bureau of Investigation analyst’s report prompted Senior District Judge Robert Mullins to vacate Deborah Nicholls’ conviction and order a new trial.
During a bond hearing, prosecutors presented Schmitt and other original investigators to argue against release, while defense attorney Janene McCabe highlighted advances in fire-science methodology. Additional experts, including John Lentini and Tom Griffin, had produced reports suggesting no ignitable liquids, but those findings were not disclosed at the original trial. Judge Catherine Helton scheduled further hearings to decide on bond and the next steps in the case.
Why it matters
The case raises questions about the reliability of forensic evidence used in capital convictions.
In this story
