Georgia Mother Seeks New Trial After Shaken-Baby Conviction Questioned
Katie Smith, serving a life sentence for the 2014 death of her son Tucker, is requesting a new trial as experts argue his death resulted from an undiagnosed brain malformation, not shaking.
In 2014, two-year-old Tucker Smith suffered a seizure and later died, leading to his mother Katie Smith's conviction for murder after a physician diagnosed shaken-baby syndrome. Since her sentencing to life imprisonment, the Southern Center for Human Rights has assembled a neurologist and a forensic pathologist who attribute Tucker's death to an undetected arteriovenous malformation that caused epilepsy. Their investigation suggests the triad of symptoms cited in shaken-baby cases can arise from various medical conditions.
Katie's attorneys have filed a motion for a new trial, scheduled for presentation on August 24 before the Richmond County Superior Court. The Augusta District Attorney's Office is contesting the request, though it has not provided comment. The case reflects a broader re-examination of shaken-baby diagnoses in the legal system.
Why it matters
The case highlights potential wrongful convictions stemming from disputed medical diagnoses in child-death prosecutions.
In this story
