Illinois Halts Assisted-Suicide Law for Nuns and Doctors Amid Religious-Liberty Lawsuits
An Illinois judge issued temporary restraining orders that stop enforcement of the new assisted-suicide statute for Catholic nuns and physicians while related lawsuits proceed.
Illinois has temporarily suspended key provisions of its newly enacted assisted-suicide law after two temporary restraining orders were issued by U.S. District Judge Franklin Valderrama. The orders, brought by the Thomas More Society and the Becket religious-liberty firm, bar the state from compelling Catholic nuns and physicians in hospitals, nursing homes and end-of-life facilities to participate in medical aid in dying.
The legislation, the first of its kind in the Midwest, was slated to become operative the day after the second TRO was granted. Cardinal Blase Cupich stressed that the objection is about preventing the state from violating the conscience of Catholic health-care providers. Illinois' pause follows a similar suspension in New York and is linked to a pending 7th Circuit case concerning compelled speech requirements for pro-life pregnancy centers. The outcome may influence how states balance assisted-suicide policies with religious-freedom claims, while Canada’s expanding medical-aid-in-dying regime provides an international backdrop.
Why it matters
The rulings could shape national precedent on reconciling assisted-suicide laws with religious-freedom rights.
In this story
