Justice Samuel Alito withdraws from high-profile climate lawsuit
Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito has announced he will no longer sit on a major climate case after pressure over his holdings in oil-related stocks.
A letter sent to lawyers in a pending climate-change case revealed that Justice Samuel Alito will not continue participating, after calls for his recusal based on stock interests in the energy sector. The case, slated for arguments next week, sees Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy attempting to throw out a Colorado lawsuit that seeks damages for climate impacts. Alito’s disclosed portfolio includes shares in ConocoPhillips, Phillips 66 and five other energy companies, though not in the two plaintiffs.
Advocacy groups contend that a favorable Supreme Court decision for Exxon and Suncor could indirectly boost the value of Alito’s holdings. Previously, Alito had recused himself from a related Colorado appeal in 2023 and from other cases involving ConocoPhillips and Phillips 66. His withdrawal now raises the possibility of a 4-4 split among the justices, which would leave the key legal questions unanswered. The oil and gas industry hopes for a broad ruling that would curb similar state-court climate suits nationwide.
How this was covered
- Right-leaning coverage is the most divided on this story
- Coverage peaked at 6 outlets in a single hour
Why it matters
Alito's exit could create a tie vote, leaving a pivotal climate-damage case unresolved and affecting future lawsuits against oil firms.
How the sides frame it
MODERATE AGREEMENTAll camps report Justice Alito’s recusal, but left-leaning coverage emphasizes his stock holdings and advocacy concerns, center coverage presents the recusal as a neutral procedural fact, and right-leaning coverage highlights pressure from left-wing groups and the impact on petitioners.
LEFT
Alito steps aside amid stock-conflict concerns raised by advocacy groups.
CENTER
Alito recuses himself from the climate case, with the court noting his holdings but offering no explanation.
RIGHT
Alito withdraws after left-wing pressure, a setback for the petitioners.
The left emphasises
- calls for recusal based on his oil-company stock holdings
- advocacy groups say a favorable decision could boost the value of his holdings
- previous recusals in related cases
The right emphasises
- pressure from left-wing groups to step aside
- recusal viewed as a setback for petitioners
- timing puzzling given earlier calls for withdrawal
In this story
Related stories
5 in this thread