NSW Police chief seeks to keep police misconduct hearings private and off-air
NSW Police Commissioner Mal Lanyon intervened at the last minute to block public, livestreamed hearings into alleged police violence during the Isaac Herzog protest.
Commissioner Mal Lanyon filed an eleventh-hour submission contesting the Law Enforcement Conduct Commission’s plan to hold public, livestreamed hearings on police conduct during the protest against Israeli President Isaac Herzog’s visit. The commission had originally set the hearings to begin no earlier than September, but postponed them citing procedural issues before reinstating an October 19 opening address. Lanyon argued that the commission lacked authority for counsel assisting to make an opening statement and that witness examinations should remain private.
Counsel assisting countered that a lack of public scrutiny would leave the community with only the final report for accountability. The investigation, known as Operation Makaru, follows more than 800 complaints and body-worn camera footage suggesting excessive force. Chief Commissioner Peter Johnson decided that senior officers would testify under pseudonyms in private sessions, while some public examinations would still proceed. NSW Police acknowledged the commission’s decision and awaits the findings.
Why it matters
The dispute determines how transparent the inquiry into alleged police brutality will be for the public.
How the sides frame it
HIGH AGREEMENTBoth camps report the commissioner’s request for closed hearings was rejected, but left-leaning coverage highlights the commissioner’s last-minute push and questions the lack of transparency, while right-leaning coverage stresses the denial as a win for public scrutiny.
LEFT
Left-leaning coverage frames the story as the police commissioner’s last-minute attempt to keep misconduct hearings private, suggesting a lack of transparency.
RIGHT
Right-leaning coverage frames the story as the rejection of the private-hearing request, emphasizing that public scrutiny is being ensured.
The left emphasises
- commissioner Mal Lanyon filed an eleventh-hour submission to keep hearings private
- counsel assisting warned that without public scrutiny the community would only get a final report
- the timing of the request was described as “regrettable”
The right emphasises
- the request for closed-door hearings was denied, ensuring public scrutiny
- the inquiry will feature live-streamed testimony from senior police officials
- Greens MP Sue Higginson criticized the police’s effort to limit transparency
In this story
Related stories
2 in this thread