PETA attacks Kristi Noem over dog shooting while offering softer critique of Abdul El-Sayed
PETA condemned former South Dakota governor Kristi Noem for shooting her 14-month-old dog, then gave a more nuanced response to Michigan Senate candidate Abdulrahman Mohamed El-Sayed’s animal-control record.
PETA launched a harsh campaign against Kristi Noem after she revealed she had shot her 14-month-old dog Cricket, calling her a "psychotic loony" and selling a Halloween costume that portrayed her as a "Puppy Killer." The organization’s response to Noem was starkly different from its handling of Michigan Democratic Senate nominee Abdulrahman Mohamed El-Sayed, who previously managed Detroit Animal Control for about 16 months.
During his leadership, reports indicate roughly 1,900 dogs and cats were euthanized, with whistleblowers describing unsanitary conditions and neglect. PETA attributed the broader problem to breeders, retailers, and owners who do not spay or adopt, and called for an independent probe into claims of denied veterinary care. The group’s contrasting approaches highlight a shift from personal vilification to systemic critique.
Additionally, El-Sayed has faced criticism for controversial remarks about Second Lady Usha Vance and Vice President JD Vance. PETA has not endorsed El-Sayed, but its statements have given him additional public exposure.
Why it matters
The story shows how advocacy groups may apply different standards to public figures, influencing political narratives.
In this story
