Rethinking Pakistan's State Functions: Extraction, Delivery and Decentralisation
A column argues that Pakistan’s development challenges stem from how the state extracts resources and delivers services, urging different reforms for each.
In a recent analysis, the writer highlights that discussions on redrawing provincial lines in Pakistan ignore the deeper problem of constitutional legitimacy. He frames state performance around two main tasks: extracting resources from citizens and delivering public services. Centralised tax measures, such as electricity tariffs and withholding taxes, have improved compliance, whereas broader tax coverage remains weak.
Conversely, improvements in literacy, school enrolment and basic health outcomes were achieved when local bodies managed schools and clinics, a trend that stalled after recent provincial centralisation. The author proposes reducing discretion in extraction through automation, while expanding decentralised authority for service delivery to boost effectiveness. He concludes that a one-size-fits-all overhaul is unnecessary; tailored reforms are needed for each function.
Why it matters
Understanding how Pakistan’s state collects revenue and provides services can shape reforms that affect millions of citizens.
In this story
