Senior doctor admits delayed police referral in Lucy Letby infant murder case
Dr Stephen Brearey says he should have alerted police sooner after suspecting Lucy Letby of infant murders at Countess of Chester Hospital.
In his first interview since the Thirlwall Inquiry report, Stephen Brearey, who headed a group of seven consultants at Countess of Chester Hospital, expressed regret for not contacting Cheshire Police earlier when he suspected nurse Lucy Letby of killing seven infants and attempting to kill seven more. He explained that he had assumed senior managers would share his concerns, yet internal reviews in 2015 and 2016 failed to trigger a police investigation until May 2017, allowing Letby to stay on staff until her July 2018 arrest.
Brearey highlighted the NHS’s "toxic negativity" that discouraged staff from speaking up and noted the absence of psychological support for the neonatal team after the tragedy. The inquiry issued 17 recommendations, including CCTV for cots and incubators, restricted insulin access, mandatory safeguarding training, and a unified NHS IT system, which he believes could have prevented or hastened detection of Letby’s crimes.
He remains cautious about the speed of cultural change within the NHS, urging the Department of Health to implement the reforms. Former hospital executives said they are reviewing the report while investigations continue.
Why it matters
The story shows how institutional failures let a nurse kill infants, highlighting urgent need for better whistle-blowing and safety safeguards in hospitals.
In this story
