SNP faces criticism for allocating Holyrood time to another independence debate
The Scottish Government will hold a Holyrood debate titled “Scotland’s right to decide,” prompting Conservative and Labour leaders to denounce the SNP for using parliamentary time on independence.
The Scottish Government plans to stage a debate on “Scotland’s right to decide” in Holyrood on Tuesday, led by First Minister John Swinney, following a recent memorandum of understanding with the leaders of Wales, Northern Ireland and Ireland on breaking up the United Kingdom. Critics from the Scottish Conservatives and Labour, including Russell Findlay and Jackie Baillie, labeled the motion a “dangerous distraction” and a “gimmick,” arguing the SNP should focus on health, education and poverty.
The SNP defended the initiative, urging new leader Michael Marra to support the motion and citing Prime Minister Andy Burnham’s remarks that a border poll could be considered when consensus emerges. MSP David Linden emphasized the principle that the Scottish people should decide their future, while the UK Government reiterated that a second referendum remains off-limits. Given the pro-independence majority in the Scottish Parliament, the motion is likely to be approved, despite Westminster’s stance.
Why it matters
The debate underscores the persistent clash over a second Scottish independence referendum and its ramifications for UK governance.
How this story developed
- Sep 12 Trump says he hopes to see a united Ireland someday
- Sep 12 Unionist leaders issued sharp criticism of Trump’s remarks.
- Sep 12 Leaders of Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland will meet in Cardiff on Monday to sign a declaration calling for independence referendums and the dissolution of the United Kingdom.
- Sep 13 The leaders are presenting the Cardiff gathering as a party‑leader dialogue rather than a formal inter‑governmental summit.
- Sep 13 Trump reiterated his support for a united Ireland at a press briefing at his Doonbeg resort.
- Sep 13 Mary Lou McDonald attended the Cardiff signing and DUP deputy Emma Little‑Pengelly denied O’Neill’s authority to represent Northern Ireland’s first‑ministerial office.
- Sep 14 Trump announced the United States would drop tariffs on Irish whiskey.
- Sep 15 Leaders signed a memorandum of understanding calling for the UK government to prepare independence referendums for Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
In this story
Related stories
21 in this thread