State audits uncover billions in unverified Medicaid and questionable unemployment payouts
Audits of New York finances found tens of billions in Medicaid payments without required electronic verification and an estimated $11 billion in possibly improper unemployment benefits.
A comprehensive analysis of New York State Comptroller audits spanning 2018 to mid-2026 identified major oversight gaps in Medicaid and unemployment insurance programs. Between January 2021 and March 2023, the state disbursed roughly $31.5 billion for Medicaid personal-care services, yet $14.5 billion of those payments had no corresponding electronic verification records. A 2024 audit noted that a blocking mechanism existed but was never turned on.
Separate reviews highlighted $21.3 million in potentially improper Medicaid claims, such as services billed while patients were hospitalized. The report also estimated $11 billion in improper unemployment benefits paid during the COVID-19 pandemic, based on extrapolated fraud rates. Further findings pointed to $1.2 billion in managed-care premiums possibly paid to individuals no longer residing in the state, and local theft cases totaling over $900,000. State Comptroller Thomas DiNapoli called for stronger safeguards and cooperation with law-enforcement agencies.
Why it matters
The findings reveal large gaps in oversight that could cost taxpayers billions and undermine confidence in vital health and unemployment programs.
In this story
