Sydney patient outraged after surgeon given only reflection task for non-consensual ops

In 2013, Sydney resident Catherine Shakespeare had surgery for a uterine prolapse performed by gynaecologist Alan Lam. She later discovered that Lam had also removed asymptomatic endometriosis and carried out a posterior vaginal wall repair and rectal wall repair without her prior consent, leading to a recto-vaginal fistula and a period living with a colostomy bag. Seeking answers, she filed a complaint with the NSW Health Care Complaints Commission in October 2021.

An expert peer review criticised the unsanctioned procedures, and the case was referred to the Medical Council, which, noting the elapsed time and no immediate public risk, ordered only that Lam write a reflection on the incident. Lam denied the allegations but later issued an apology through his insurer. Shakespeare remains angry, saying the regulator’s response fell short of an apology or accountability, and she is preparing for further surgery to address ongoing complications.