The Proclaimers face criticism after gender-critical remarks on trans issues
Scottish musicians Craig and Charlie Reid sparked outrage by describing women as "adult human females" and labeling pro-trans views as "truth-phobic" in a recent interview.
Ahead of their new album release, the twin singers Craig and Charlie Reid made a series of statements that women are "adult human females" and that those who support transgender rights are "truth-phobic" and deny biological reality. Craig further defended gender-critical commentator Graham Linehan, describing the loss of his career for speaking his mind as a tragedy, though he noted disagreement with some of Linehan's views.
Trans activist India Willoughby labeled the duo a disappointment, emphasizing that trans people are a natural part of humanity and that trans hate is not a mere opinion. Equality Amplified founder Thomas Willett criticized the media for amplifying celebrity opinions on trans issues, calling the remarks part of a broader anti-trans narrative. The comments prompted a wave of backlash on social platforms, with fans and observers decrying the band's stance as aligned with right-wing rhetoric.
Why it matters
The remarks highlight ongoing cultural battles over transgender rights and the influence of celebrity opinions on public discourse.
In this story
