Trump issues narrower birthright citizenship orders, sparking fresh legal debate
President Trump signed two executive orders aimed at limiting birthright citizenship and curbing birth tourism, prompting mixed reactions from legal scholars.
Following a June Supreme Court decision affirming citizenship for children of undocumented parents, President Trump issued two new executive orders to narrow birthright citizenship and target birth tourism. The first, signed on August 6, instructs federal agencies to refuse citizenship paperwork for children whose parents belong to foreign terrorist organizations, work for foreign governments, or have engaged in fraudulent schemes to obtain U.S. citizenship.
Legal analysts from right-leaning think tanks cite long-standing exceptions for diplomats and enemy combatants, citing United States v. Wong Kim Ark. A second order empowers the State Department and Homeland Security to deny visas or pursue removal of suspected birth-tourism participants, invoking INA Section 215(a). Critics, including scholars from the University of Virginia and the Cato Institute, argue the president is exceeding constitutional limits and that existing visa rules already address the issue.
Litigation is underway, with a Maryland judge set to consider an injunction on August 28 and a related motion pending in New Hampshire. The orders remain on the books but are slated to become effective on September 6.
Why it matters
The orders could reshape how citizenship is granted and test the limits of executive authority over immigration law.
In this story
