Washington Archdiocese’s Vaccine Policy Sparks Religious-Liberty Concerns Among Catholic Parents
Catholic families say the Archdiocese of Washington refuses to honor Maryland’s religious exemption for childhood vaccines, prompting them to leave its schools.
The Archdiocese of Washington has altered Maryland’s health-immunization certificate, eliminating the section that allows parents to claim a religious objection to vaccines. This move forces compliance with state vaccination mandates, even though Maryland law expressly permits such exemptions outside emergencies. In contrast, the Archdiocese of Baltimore and the Diocese of Arlington follow state law and even state that immunization is not required for participation in religious education.
The authors reference Church documents, including the Pontifical Academy for Life’s 2005 reflections and the 2020 note on COVID-19 vaccines, which affirm the legitimacy of conscientious objections. They contend that Catholic schools should support parental authority rather than override sincerely held beliefs. The policy’s rigidity risks driving families toward secular private schools or homeschooling, potentially worsening enrollment declines in Catholic education. The piece calls on the Washington archdiocese to adopt a religious accommodation consistent with Maryland and neighboring dioceses.
Why it matters
The policy may push Catholic families out of church schools, affecting religious education and enrollment trends.
In this story