Defense and prosecutors spar over AMLC confidentiality in Duterte impeachment trial
During the 32nd day of Vice President Sara Duterte's impeachment trial, her lawyers asked to postpone AMLC Executive Director Ronell Buenaventura's testimony, citing insufficient time to review confidential records.
On the 32nd day of the impeachment proceedings against Vice President Sara Duterte, the defense sought to defer the testimony of AMLC Executive Director Ronell Buenaventura, arguing that they had not been given adequate time to study the extensive confidential records. Attorney Sheila Sison cited Section 8-A of Republic Act 11521, which requires AMLC employees to safeguard information, and contended that the July court order authorizing the subpoena did not preclude additional confidentiality challenges.
Prosecutor Di Ok countered that the defense had access to all AMLC documents since early September and that the confidentiality provision cannot nullify a constitutional subpoena. He referenced prior Sandiganbayan subpoenas to AMLC officials as precedent. Senator-Judge Francis Escudero, presiding over the impeachment court, said he would allow extra time so both the defense and the senator-judges could review the materials before the witness appears on Monday. The postponement was granted as a matter of courtesy and equity.
How the sides frame it
LOW AGREEMENTLeft-leaning coverage stresses the legal authority allowing the AMLC to provide financial data to the impeachment panel, while centrist coverage focuses on the procedural clash over confidentiality and the defense’s request to defer AMLC testimony.
LEFT
Highlights the AMLC’s legal basis and rule-based permission to share financial information with the Senate impeachment panel.
CENTER
Frames the story as a dispute between defense and prosecutors over the confidentiality of AMLC records and the timing of testimony.
The left emphasises
- AMLC rules permit the agency to exchange information with foreign financial intelligence units
- legal basis for the council’s cooperation with the Senate panel
- authorization to furnish financial documents to the impeachment tribunal
Related stories
35 in this thread