DOJ orders California counties to set aside and verify mail ballots suspected of non‑citizen votes
The Justice Department has sent letters to election officials in at least 18 California counties demanding that any mail‑in ballots whose voters cannot be confirmed as U.S. citizens be isolated pending verification. The letters give a 48‑hour window to submit personal identifiers such as Social Security numbers, IDs or registration copies for individuals on a list of 1,133 "likely aliens" and to segregate the associated ballots, not to discard them.
First Assistant U.S. Attorney Bilal Essayli warned that processing a ballot from a non‑citizen could constitute a federal crime and that officials could face prosecution. California officials say they lack an independent system to verify citizenship and argue that separating already‑processed ballots is impractical. A federal appeals panel has directed the state to answer the DOJ’s emergency filing by Saturday, while a hearing on the underlying lawsuit is scheduled for Tuesday.
How this was covered
- Right-leaning outlets covered this 2h later
- Right-leaning coverage is the most divided on this story
Why it matters
The dispute could affect how millions of mail‑in votes are handled in the upcoming midterm election.
How the sides frame it
HIGH AGREEMENTAll camps report the DOJ's directive to California counties to isolate and verify ballots suspected of belonging to non-citizens, but left-leaning coverage frames it as a politically motivated overreach based on faulty data, centrist coverage presents the legal clash and procedural details more neutrally, and right-leaning coverage stresses the threat of non-citizen voting and portrays the DOJ action as necessary enforcement.
LEFT
Portrays the DOJ action as a politically motivated overreach built on erroneous data that threatens voter disenfranchisement
CENTER
Reports the DOJ directive, the legal dispute and procedural specifics while noting both federal and state positions
RIGHT
Emphasizes the danger of non-citizen voting and casts the DOJ’s move as essential enforcement against fraud
The left emphasises
- DOJ failures
- flawed database
- politically reckless
- threatens disenfranchisement
The right emphasises
- non-citizen voting threat
- California lacks verification system
- DOJ will not look the other way
- charges against 28 non-citizens
How this story developed
- Oct 14 DOJ orders California to vet suspected non-citizen voters within 48 hours
- Oct 22 California Attorney General Rob Bonta filed a petition to block the DOJ’s request to set aside the flagged ballots.
- Oct 24 A federal appeals panel set a Saturday deadline for California to respond to the DOJ’s emergency filing.
Related stories
10 in this thread