Kapil Sibal accuses CEC Gyanesh Kumar of unilateral SIR decisions and seeks removal
Rajya Sabha member Kapil Sibal charged chief election commissioner Gyanesh Kumar with making unilateral decisions during the Special Intensive Revision, demanding his ouster and a Supreme Court probe.
During a parliamentary session, Kapil Sibal accused chief election commissioner Gyanesh Kumar of bypassing the three-member Election Commission by issuing decisions unilaterally in the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) exercise. He referenced an internal statement that acknowledged a lack of unanimity and pointed to objections filed by commissioners Sukhbir Singh Sandhu and Vivek Joshi concerning electoral-roll modifications, IT system changes, and the SIR process.
Sibal argued that elections held in Bihar in June 2025 and West Bengal in April were therefore illegal and called for the Supreme Court to examine the Commission’s records, dissent notes, and orders, and to consider annulling those polls. He also demanded that an FIR be lodged against Seima Khanna, who manages the ECINET platform, asserting she lacks statutory immunity. The Election Commission responded by announcing a review committee with an independent IIT/IIIT expert, confirming that certain Form 6 changes were upheld by the Supreme Court, and pledging to circulate agendas and minutes for future meetings.
Why it matters
The allegations question the integrity of India's election administration and could affect the legitimacy of recent state elections.
How this story developed
- Sep 23 Election Commission denies internal dissent, says all decisions were unanimous
- Sep 23 Congress senior filed a petition urging the Supreme Court to intervene and summon the Election Commission members.
- Sep 25 A Supreme Court petition seeking criminal prosecution of the chief election commissioner was filed.
- Sep 26 The Election Commission announced that Booth Level Officers will visit voters flagged in the SIR to collect supporting documents, with online hearings and additional help desks to be established.
In this story
Related stories
17 in this thread