Legal scholar slams Pentagon plan to broadcast Nidal Hasan execution
Georgetown law professor Steve Vladeck condemned the Defense Secretary’s idea to livestream the execution of former Army psychiatrist Nidal Hasan, calling it a reckless spectacle.
In a Substack essay, constitutional expert Steve Vladeck sharply criticized the Pentagon’s proposal to livestream the execution of Nidal Hasan, labeling it "colossally stupid." He warned that the broadcast could serve Hasan’s own extremist aims and doubted the Supreme Court would intervene, given its recent turn toward originalist interpretations of the Eighth Amendment. Vladeck referenced the Court’s 2019 Bucklew decision and the 1879 Wilkerson case to show that historical standards may now support such a public display.
He also pointed out that Hasan is unlikely to pursue further legal appeals. The commentary extended to moral objections, echoing former judge Alex Kozinski’s description of executions as brutal and savage. Vladeck concluded that the spectacle highlights how evolving judicial views can shape the limits of constitutional protections.
Why it matters
The debate raises questions about government transparency, the limits of constitutional rights, and the potential glorification of violent extremists.
How this story developed
- Oct 1 A grim tally of botched executions from hanging mishaps to lethal-injection failures
- Oct 5 President Donald Trump has approved a firing squad execution for former Army psychiatrist Nidal Hasan, the 2009 Fort Hood mass shooter.
- Oct 6 Pentagon announced the execution will be carried out by firing squad.
- Oct 7 Execution date set for Dec 3.
- Oct 8 Pentagon confirmed the execution will be livestreamed.
- Oct 9 British cabinet minister Bridget Phillipson called the US decision to livestream a firing-squad execution of Nidal Hasan "disturbing" and reiterated Britain’s opposition to capital punishment.
- Oct 9 Survivor Alonzo Lunsford voiced support for the execution method while warning that a livestream could be misused.
- Oct 9 Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth disclosed that the execution will be carried out by firing squad and streamed online.
- Oct 9 Acting Army Secretary Adam Telle confirmed the execution date and firing‑squad method.
- Oct 10 State leaders announced a review of execution methods following the failed lethal injection.
- Oct 11 President Trump said the decision on whether to livestream the execution remains pending.
In this story
Related stories
17 in this thread